“Taurus” v.s. “Stairway to Heaven” v.s. “Let it Grow”

Everything is a remix part 1 shows how Led Zeppelin unashamedly ripped off Taurus: a band whom they had toured with early on in their career.

Stairway to Heaven”(1971), possesses almost the exact same guitar riff/chord sequence as “Taurus” (1968) by Spirit. This is not however the only similarity:

  • The tempo of each song is almost identical – slow and dreamy.
  • The instrumentation is very similar. “Stairway”’s intro features acoustic guitar playing the main riff + woodwind, “Spirit” also consists of acoustic guitar playing the main riff, + strings.
  • The title/subject of each song is closely related. Led Zeppelin are basically singing about a spirit who is climbing the Stairway to Heaven.
  • Both songs are designed to evoke spiritual and mystical imagery.

Led Zeppelin used “Spirit” as the blueprint for “Stairway”, not only emulating the mood and style of the song but copying musical passages note for note to the point where you could easily confuse both songs on listening to them.

I take the same view as fellow ReTechSocial blogger Anthony Minshull with regards to Led Zeppelin’s plagiarism. The fact that they went through their illustrious career copying the work of others note for note and lyric for lyric without referencing their sources is what makes their case quite astonishing. They profited hugely through ultimately stealing other peoples ideas and passing them off as their own. Their gains were not only financial: Led Zeppelin are consistently put on a pedestal and labelled as one of the best rock bands of all time, and I am sure this will continue to be the case. They didn’t just take influence and make something new from something old: they took, used and exploited the fact that their sources did not have the same high-profile.

There is another song to add to the mix. The verse of “Let It Grow” by Eric Clapton heavily features a guitar passage which closely resembles the main riffs heard in Spirit/Stairway to Heaven”. Check it out:

Clapton eventually confessed in his autobiography (2008) that it was several years before I realized that I had totally ripped off ‘Stairway to Heaven,’ the famous Zeppelin anthem”.

He claims that he subconsciously copied Led Zeppelin. Whether this is true or not is hard to tell. What do you think? Ok, the feel and emotion in the song is a different in “Let It Grow, but the guitar riff is still in my opinion a little too close for comfort. I have no doubt that this affects my enjoyment of the song because it is so distinctive and a centre-piece of the song.

In my last blog I looked at Star Wars and its origins. Interestingly the obvious copying of other works without reference that George Lucas performed does not affect my enjoyment of Star Wars. By mimicking and remixing an incredible amount of different sources of inspiration and blending them, Lucas created a multi-layered film which retains a strong feeling of originality. It is also very easy to engage with. His approach to remixing is very interesting and innovative, particularly when compared to the songwriting methodology employed by Led Zeppelin in this instance.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Audio, Copyright, Everything is a remix, Star Wars and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to “Taurus” v.s. “Stairway to Heaven” v.s. “Let it Grow”

  1. ric says:

    clapton, page, yardbirds

  2. stevewhelan1@yahoo.com says:

    There is a big difference between influenced and copied. Should we give the Beatles and Stones royalties on everything after 1975? The nature of new music is that it draws from our experiences and peers. That is not copying.. The totality of the two songs are completely different. Count how may songs are like Johnny B. Goode? You’ll run out of fingers and toes even in a crowded room!

    • guregor11 says:

      Totality ok, yes, the structures of each song are different and progress in differing ways. However in my opinion there are elements which are too similar to be classed as mere influence. As a songwriter myself, with any guitar or keyboard riff I write which I deem too similar to something I have heard I either work to alter it or discard it. As an artist I want to avoid going over old ground. Anyone who does there best to emulate almost completely, or try and pass off something as completely their own creation I instantly lose respect for. Led Zeppelin profited considerably from passing off musical elements by lesser known artists as their own, not changing them enough to make them their own. Laziness if you ask me, but fair play they wrote a good tune using someone else’s riff without appropriate referencing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s